This season of idol seems to have something for everyone. There are some very diverse styles here, which can make it very entertaining, but also leave the results kind of random. You never know which demographic will carry the evening.

I love Carly as well - but I have concerns about the tightness in her high notes. It's surprising given the support & power she has in the middle register. If she could overcome this, she would be unbeatable.

David A. is a sweetie, and talented for sure. Sometimes he seems a bit too 'studied' for me, but this will come with maturity I think.

I honestly don't have a favorite this season, and will be curious to see who ends up at the top.

To answer your question franko, I do think David H. was dismissed early based on the controversy about his past.